Skip to main content

You know the world is topsy turvy when, on a Monday morning, you find it more heart-wrenching to send your child off to kindergarten than to bring her twin sister to a pediatric cancer clinic for chemotherapy.

Like mothers across the nation, I am absolutely heartbroken over what happened in Newtown on Friday. The fact that my daughters are just shy of six, and that it happened just miles away from my hometown, have made it that much more visceral and immediate. I still find myself crying over it several times a day. It’s nearly impossible to process — especially at what’s such a joyous and magical time of year for young kids.

The Internet and the blogosphere abound with powerful responses to the tragedy. People have made passionate pleas for gun law reform and assault weapons bans, they’ve made the case for better access to mental health care, and have lamented our culture of violence. I agree with all of it, and won’t attempt to duplicate those messages here.

But I do want to share my perspective as the mother of a child who is fighting a life-threatening disease.

Our life changed completely one day last summer when we found out that our five-year-old daughter, Clio, had leukemia. Suddenly, everything else in our lives — our work, our plans, our ordinary routine — was rendered insignificant next to our quest to get save our daughter’s life.

Since her diagnosis, we have endured hospital stays and harrowing side effects. Currently, we bring her to the clinic for chemo twice a week. We give her all manner of medications at home, and are constantly vigilant against germs and infections. Her treatment will go on for another two years, and only three years after that will she be considered “cured,” assuming she doesn’t relapse.

Her chances of survival are excellent — around 90% — and we are hopeful. But the first weeks after her diagnosis, when we weren’t sure of her prognosis, were absolute hell. In anguished moments I thought: why couldn’t I have cancer instead? Even now, I’d trade places with her in a heartbeat if I could, to spare her the discomfort, the missed opportunities, the anxiety.

I suspect that any of the parents of those innocent little children killed on Friday would do exactly the same thing. If they could go back in time and alter things such that they were the ones in the path of that deranged gunman, instead of their babies, they would.

It feels callous, in some way, to be grateful — beyond grateful, there are no words for how grateful — that this didn’t happen to my children. And yet, of course, I am. I am grateful beyond words that I have the chance to fight tooth and nail and heart and soul for my daughter’s life.

The parents of those twenty children didn’t have that chance.

I have the sum knowledge of years of scientific and medical research, powerful medications, and the support of dedicated and compassionate nurses, doctors and other staff,  all being put toward saving my child’s life.

The parents of those children didn’t have any of that.

My child’s life is threatened only by biology — a series of chance genetic mutations. There is nobody and nothing to blame — no evil intent, no man-made machines, no laws or cultural norms. Nothing could have prevented her illness from happening in the first place.

If, God forbid, she did die from her disease, I would feel no malice toward anyone or anything. While I would be devastated, to be sure, that devastation wouldn’t be compounded with fury and incomprehension as to how something so horrible could happen.

I would have a chance to say goodbye. Those parents didn’t have a chance.

My child only has cancer. Only. I never thought I’d feel grateful for this fact.

17 Comments

  • Asha Stager says:

    Oh Jane, this made me weep yet again. Your words express so eloquently my feelings……..and especially that ending sentence: “I would have a chance to say goodbye. Those parents didn’t have a chance.” This is one of my own deepest sadnesses……that I didn’t have a chance to say goodbye to Carl. My heart is with all those parents………and with you and Clio and Elsa and Alastair. I have been so fortunate to have watched you grow up into the wise woman you are! Love, Asha

  • Guajolote says:

    Oh jesus. Man. That’s the conclusion I figured this post would come to. But, MAN. 🙁

  • Laurie says:

    I was fine until the last line. Even though I knew it was coming, I still burst into tears. I have been fretting that my daughter (in 8th grade) didn’t have sufficient time to study for her two exams today. I have been mad at myself for not realizing how much studying she needed to do. I have been frustated by what has seemed to be poor planning by teachers and how I would have done things differently (I am an educator too). Your post is the “slap in the face” that I needed. So what if she didn’t have enough study time? So what if her grades on the exams aren’t great? What stupid things for me to fret over. I have my child, a happy, healthy, wonderful daughter. I have no right to fret over such silly stuff. What a privilege it is that I can even worry about such mundane things. I have a daughter and she is alive. Thank you, Jane, for this most needed reminder.

  • Maggie may says:

    … ‘ until i met a man who had no legs… ‘

    that famous quote, your beautiful heart. thank you.

  • Cheryl says:

    Beautiful. The piece and the spirit of the writer. <3

  • Korinthia says:

    This post gave me flashbacks to those feelings of being grateful that my husband was simply deployed in a war zone and not coming home in a body bag. It’s all relative sometimes.

    Good thoughts your way as always. Have a lovely holiday.

  • Ewokmama says:

    I could not have said it better myself.

  • April says:

    Beautifully well written and such profound truth to it. Getting to say good bye is a big one. Often I am rushed getting the boys out the door in the mornings and sometimes snap at them or yell. Letting that be the last things they heard from me would kill me. Sometimes I can be at peace with death as long as I feel I got to say goodbye. I was okay with my grandfather’s death because I got to say goodbye and I was the last person to probably see him and speak to him before he died in his sleep. Even though he was sleeping it means something that I could see him and tell him goodbye and kiss his forehead.

    Not getting that chance would make it so much harder.

    You keep fighting the good fight for Clio. You are doing an amazing job.

  • Amber Rush says:

    Wow…That was very powerful and moving. As always, thank you for sharing your thoughts. Hugs to you, Clio and Elsa.

  • Jen in MN says:

    Thank you for sharing your unique (to me) perspective on this. It just about took my breath away, especially your opening and closing paragraphs.

    Your eloquently-shared perspective helps me in mine. This is frequently the case, I find, as you share your journey of Clio’s cancer these past few months.

    Thank you for writing, for sharing, for persisting through it all.

    Wishing you and you entire family a safe, merry, lovely holiday!

  • Veronica says:

    Thank you Jane. This is so heart wrenching. To think of your new perspective and what had to happen for you to even think that. There is no word really to describe the horror that Friday has brought and the lack of being able to say goodbye is its own level of trauma for these poor parents. Thanks for sharing.

  • Mom Betsy says:

    Powerful words my dear daughter!

  • Isabelle says:

    Thank you for this beautiful post. My father passed away tonight and your words which I had read earlier today were very comforting to me. He did have cancer although he died of what we think was heart failure. But because he had cancer for more than a year and a half we had a long time to be in a peaceful, loving place and although we did not get to say the goodbye in the way I had hoped to we were in a sense saying good bye for the past few months. Thank you for sharing your perspective through your eloquent writing.

    • Katie says:

      I am so sorry about your dad. My father passed away in June. He had cancer as well, yet it was a different form than previously thought that killed him 1 week after the “new” diagnosis. He was home from the hospital for one day before passing. We got to do goodbyes, although like you, not how we wanted to. I have since had 2 dreams with him in it, although he is far away in those dreams, I get to see his face and his goofy smile. As long as I have that, I will be ok. I felt the need to respond to your post of all of them because it hit close to home. I guess its like Jane said… at least we got a goodbye, even if not how we imagined. Thanks for posting.

  • Rosstwinmom says:

    Thank you for sharing your perspective; it helps me sort through my feelings. Though, I still cry when you say Clio has cancer.

  • Alison says:

    Thanks, Jane, for all your writing and especially these lovely words at such a time. Here’s a similar sentiment from a mom whose daughter died after a long, incurable illness: http://www.beautifulcanvas.org/2012/12/remembering/comment-page-1/#comment-15068 I shared your post with her, too – such different families and situations, but such a similar feeling.

  • mandy says:

    Jane, This was so moving to read. I’ve been having trouble putting anything about Newtown into words. I’m so sorry for Clio’s struggle. I’m glad you don’t feel angry and that her prognosis is good. But so sorry she has to go through it.